Don't Overlook the Potential of Starter

Published in the May 2013 Issue Published online: May 31, 2013 Dr. Mike Stewart
Viewed 923 time(s)

The benefits of placing a portion of the crop's fertilizer needs in a concentrated band at planting have long been recognized.

Placing some of the needed phosphorus (P), nitrogen (N), potassium (K) and other nutrients near (starter) or with the seed (pop-up) at planting can result in a striking early season response that results in quicker canopy cover, decreased erosion potential and enhanced competition with weeds. While starter fertilizer is used in the production of many crops, corn is the most common and probably the most studied.

Several factors affect response to starter fertilizer. Soil conditions that increase the likelihood of response include cool soil temperature at planting and root growth restrictions such as soil compaction, soil acidity and soil salinity. The response to P and K is usually expected to decrease as soil test levels increase. However, this may not always be true with starter applied P and K as these stress factors (soil temperature, etc.) can overshadow the effect of soil test level. So starter fertilizer may be beneficial where early cool, moist soil conditions prevail, even though soil test P and K levels are high. An example of this is shown in a three-year Kansas study where a 30-30-5 starter treatment increased corn yield over a 30-30-0 treatment 11 bu/A in soil that tested very high in K.

There are synergistic effects among nutrients in starters. For example, N and P work together in a band. Nitrogen, in the ammonium form, results in the production of acidity in the zone of soil right around the root. This can increase P uptake within the same band. Nitrogen and P can cause roots to proliferate in the zone where starter fertilizer was applied. Potassium does not proliferate roots, so co-application with N and/or P is needed for roots to more fully explore the K supply in the starter. Phosphorus also supplies needed energy early in the plant for the active uptake of K.

Placement in a 2x2 configuration (2 inches to the side and 2 inches below the seed) is the standard for starter fertilizer. Early in its development, corn has roots that grow down and to the side, at about a 45-degree angle. Nutrients placed 2x2 are well placed for access by the young root system. But, because of factors such as equipment cost, time and residue a 2x2 system is not the easiest to implement. One study has indicated that a "dribble" 2x0 (surface applied 2 inches from the seed) application can perform about as well as 2x2. When averaged across several starter formulations, each configuration increased yield by just over 30 bu/A.

The most commonly observed effect of starter fertilizer is more rapid early season growth. This effect alone has benefits (as described above), but it does not always guarantee increased yield. As a plant continues to develop its roots explorer more soil, so the dependence on starter applied nutrients is diminished with time. End of season yield response depends on how quickly and to what extent a plant root system accesses other supplies of nutrients in the soil, which is in turn related to the degree of stress in early season. Under conditions where root exploration is limited or slowed, yield response is more likely.

The use of starter fertilizer is an effective management practice that is based on sound agronomic principles. But in most cases it should not be the sole fertility program. The best approach to starter is to view it as a catalyst that promotes rapid and uniform growth for a crop that will have adequate and balanced available nutrients in the soil rooting volume as the season progresses.